Insurance company....which one?

Ok, currently I'm on USAA. I feel I pay WAAAAAAY too much. I'm shopping around and would like to know what companies people have had good/bad experience with.

While I haven't gotten a quote yet, I'm considering Amica the most based upon some of my friends' rates with them....does anybody use them? Has anybody filed a claim? None of my friends have filed a claim with them, and that's when the truth comes out about which insurance companies are good....the price is only part of it.

Ok, so here's what I've got:

2 cars. '88 Volvo, '01 Accord. I pay more for the Accord liability than the Volvo.....

I pay something like $1100/6 mos. with USAA. Under 25 male, flawless driving record. No tickets (except one for noise violation when my friend cranked up the stereo in his car, he was drunk, I was DD, shoulda fought in court, long story....), no claims, no wrecks. One driver (me), reasonable coverage with $500 deductable....I don't recall how much insurance I have for things, but it's pretty reasonable, something like 50/100 liability (50/person, 100/accident) or something like that.

So.....here's the list of questions:
Who are you with?
What's your rate?
How many drivers on the policy?
What's your driving record like?
What's your coverage like?
Have you filed any claims? How was their service?

b